11 Prospect Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

4 bd · 2.5 ba · 1,994 sqft · built 1890 · Shelter Island Heights · SINGLE_FAMILY·source listing ↗

$2,595,000

rent, three ways

OnePercent model (vv1)$3,397/mo

p10–p90 confidence band

HUD Fair Market Rent · 11965 · 4BR$4,000/mo

Area comps median (last 90d)—

FMR from HUD SAFMR FY2026. Never a naked estimate.

County

Suffolk

Flood risk indexRelatively Low FEMA NRI

Median household income—

Median area rent—

Median home value$1,113,600