171J N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11963

3 bd · 4.5 ba · 3,000 sqft · built 2000 · Shelter Island · SINGLE_FAMILY·source listing ↗

$2,595,000

rent, three ways

OnePercent model (vv1)$12,408/mo

wide honest range — HUD/comp anchors · $4,830–$12,408

HUD Fair Market Rent · 11963 · 3BR$4,830/mo

Area comps median (last 90d)—

FMR from HUD SAFMR FY2026. Never a naked estimate.

County

Suffolk

Flood risk indexRelatively Moderate FEMA NRI

Median household income$127,746

Median area rent$2,969/mo

Median home value$1,208,000