488 Tally Ho Rd, Middletown, NY 10940

1 bd · 1 ba · 748 sqft · built 1940 · Middletown · SINGLE_FAMILY·source listing ↗

$165,000

$175,000 first listed

seller intel

Price cut

−5.7%

from $175,000

Motivation score

31/100

OnePercent model (vv1)$1,874/mo

p10–p90 confidence band

HUD Fair Market Rent · 10940 · 1BR$1,600/mo

Area comps median (last 90d)—

FMR from HUD SAFMR FY2026. Never a naked estimate.

County

Orange

Flood risk indexRelatively High FEMA NRI

Median household income$87,080

Median area rent$1,673/mo

Median home value$336,500

the verdict

1.14%vs 1.0% target

financing: 20% down · — (FRED, live) · 30yr

$165,000

1.14% · rent $1,874

Intrinsic value · income approach

$267,832

38% below intrinsic value

Value = net operating income ÷ market cap rate. Not investment advice.

Ten-year owner return

Equity multiple, per-year cash flow, and appreciation modeling are a Pro feature.