Loading...
market report · 11953
Middle Island, NY · 11953
21 active listings$409,999 median ask$2,701 est. rent0.7% price/rent
$409,999
Median list price
$2,701/mo
Estimated rent
0.7%
Price / rent ratio
21
Listings
FHFA home price index · 2016–2025
106.2% cumulative change over the window. Source: FHFA ZIP-level HPI.
$2.49
Median rent / sqft
21 comps
$308.03
Median sold / sqft
21 comps
—
Walkability
3.6%
Area unemployment
BLS LAUS
Median household income $86,206 · median home value $397,800 · ACS 2024.
Natural-hazard risk Relatively Low (FEMA NRI score 41).
4 schools within ~4 km of the ZIP centroid.
top deals · highest rent-to-price
58 Bailey Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
Middle Island, NY
$199,000$2,206/mo1.1%
99 Fairview Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953
Middle Island, NY
$285,000$2,683/mo0.9%
528 Lake Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
Middle Island, NY
$269,000$2,468/mo0.9%
282 Artist Lake Dr, Middle Island, NY 11953
Middle Island, NY
$240,000$2,178/mo0.9%
244 Lake Pointe Cir, Middle Island, NY 11953
Middle Island, NY
$275,000$2,488/mo0.9%
137 Fieldstone Ct, Middle Island, NY 11953
Middle Island, NY
$349,000$3,075/mo0.9%